A Death In Texas
Posted September 19th, 2007 by alex kane
As Steve Earle relates at the end of his narrative, " I know that the lives of other people who [Jonathon Nobles] came in contact with changed as well, including mine. In the beginning, Earle seems to accept Nobles at face value, a man "guilty of crimes he was charged with". With time, however, his opinion begins to change. Through their ten year correspondence, Earle begins to see the positive effects rehabilitation can produce in the men society has given up on. Earle even uses Nobles as strength in his fighting his own drug addiction. By the time of Nobles' execution, Earle truly believes in the power of one man, guilty or innocent, to change himself and inspire those around him.
- alex kane's blog
- Login or register to post comments

RSS Feed
Comments
Change
I definitely think that one of the more important things to see here is how people can change. It said that Jonathon Nobles didn't even say anything at his trial, he was convicted off his own confession and didn't flinch when his sentence was read. Then at the end of the story he was apologizing profusely to the family of the ones he killed and giving heart felt apologies and thanks. Meanwhile he had used a correspondent and a confidant, Steve Earle, as a way to change himself and to make things better. In turn, I also feel like he affected Steve Earle to want to better himself and see an improvement in both of them. It's important to note that even people who are considered to be "bad" people can still change and possibly help those around them to see their errors and stop before things end up too sour. I think this also points to how we can look in the change that comes to a person in jail, and to reasons why the death penalty has been abolished in most states. This can represent that there is still hope in change that can come around in a person, which is what is asked by the author in the end.
A Death in Texas
I think what is most impressive about this story is the impact that Jon's change has on other people. I think by showing other people that he can go from a murderer to a religious, loving person can open the public's eyes to the fact that change is possible, even for people who commit horrific crimes. A man who committed murder has gained respect and friendship of people around him like the prison clerk, the guards giving him extra time and a receptionist at the prison telling Earle how, "Jon's a good guy" (386). I think it is obvious he has changed, but the fact is that he committed terrible crimes 12 years ago and under the law has to pay for them. It is possible for people to change, but it is hard to forget what they did in the past.
Death in Texas
Will, you make a very valid point. The American justice system is here to rehabilitate people and provide consequences for their crimes. Granted it doesn't always work, but I feel Jon has taken an obvious positive step in his life. But as you stated, it is very hard to forget the past, especially when someone has committed horrific crimes. Jon, though, I think serves as a positive example of why we have a justice system: to help individuals realize they error of their ways. Granted not everyone can or will change, but some people make the effort towards being a positive influence after they've done wrong.