RSS Feed      About/Contact Dan

A Good Man...

The example of deceit that stood out the most to me in this story was the self-deception on the parts of the grandmother and The Misfit.

The grandmother, who appears to regard herself as a good person, tries to instill in her grandchildren good values and teach them to be well behaved children. She tells them that in her time, children were more respectful and expresses disapproval when her granddaughter is rude to Red Sam's wife. Meanwhile, the grandmother is constantly judging others, lying to get her way, and displaying other characteristics which go against the Christianity she later professes. When telling her grandchildren about the suitor she had in her younger days, she finishes by saying that she should have married him since he ended up buying stock in Coca-Cola and dieing with a lot of material worth. She makes no mention of whether or not he was a good person.

The Misfit also has clearly deceived himself. Then entire time he is speaking, he preaches that he is not a bad person. He believes that the crime one commits does not matter since in the end all you remember is the punishment. He tries to paint himself in the light of a victim, and at one point even compares himself to Jesus. But no matter how deceitful he is with himself it doesn't change the fact that he is a murderer.

Comments

On target

I think you're right on target with the self-deception theory. The grandmother is a lot like most of the older generation family members I grew up around. She's very much the matriarch (or tries to be) and preaches what she believes to be the truth whether or not there is any depth behind it (talking of the rich man as a "good" man). I think at the end of the story, in her near-death moments, she realizes that not all "good" is based on money, society, or past transgressions. (Even if she doesn't realize it, she does her best to make the Misfit believe it.)

As far as the Misfit goes, he too deceives himself. At first going along with the grandmother and believing that he comes from good blood and is, deep down, a good man. At the end though, I believe he faces his own truths and rather than allow her to talk him down, gives in to his dominant (and most likely true) tendencies as a killer.

A good Man

I agree with your thought on self-deception. I think the Misfit bought into the idea that there is no chance for an honest life after prison, and that was his main problem. I think there is some deception with the idea of religion. I'm having trouble putting it together, but I feel like the author is trying to say something about religion. Maybe that the Grandma was deceived by her religion, I'm not sure....

Back to top